Summary: In another effort to bring software patents back to the US (they are currently being swatted like flies in the courts), the lobby of the patent ‘industry’ gangs up with former officials of the USPTO — now in lobbying capacity — and a new report is issued regarding Section 101
THE lobby for software patents has not grown tired, even though (or because) patents on software are pretty much worthless now. Courts and boards trash them one by one (when these are actually scrutinised by people who are not USPTO examiners).
We keep a close eye on this lobby and report on its nefarious modus operandi. They don’t want their actions to be so visible.
“We keep a close eye on this lobby and report on its nefarious modus operandi.”After constantly attacking and maybe even defaming Michelle Lee, Watchtroll publishes “The next PTO Director must grasp the fundamental fact that a patent secures a property right” (lobbying disguised as news, even entering Google News). It would be a rather benign opinion piece if Watchtroll hadn’t engaged in a nasty smear campaign to leave the USPTO void of leadership (except interim).
This same nasty site has just published “The Myth of Patent Quality” as if the notion of patent quality (like level of triviality) is simply mythology. “First,” it says, “the Patent Office was issuing bad software patents that were overly vague and impinged on big tech operations.”
They play the “rotten apple” card. It’s a classic old trick.
“It would be a rather benign opinion piece if Watchtroll hadn’t engaged in a nasty smear campaign to leave the USPTO void of leadership (except interim).”On the other side, or the opposition lobby, we have groups such as United for Patent Reform.
“86 biz from retailers to automakers urge Congress to preserve #USPTO’s #IPR program that helps fight #patenttrolls,” it wrote yesterday. It’s about PTAB reviews (petitions to reconsider granted patents). “Small & large businesses from automakers to printers tell Congress,” it added, that “#IPR is vital to fight abusive #patenttrolls.”
What we have here is basically a battle between practicing companies (that make things) and the patent microcosm which makes nothing and merely profits from lawsuits. This sort of chasm is not new.
“What we have here is basically a battle between practicing companies (that make things) and the patent microcosm which makes nothing and merely profits from lawsuits.”A Section 101 report
[PDF] has just been issued by the USPTO, which also published a blog post about it. “New Report Presents Viewpoints on Patent Subject Matter Eligibility,” Joe Matal wrote, describing himself as “Performing the Functions and Duties of the Under Secretary of Commerce for Intellectual Property and Director of the USPTO” (after Michelle Lee left).
Matal writes this:”Between 2010 and 2014, four opinions issued by the U.S. Supreme Court—Bilski, Mayo, Myriad, and Alice—significantly affected patent eligibility law. Following these rulings, the USPTO provided updated guidance to patent examiners, initiated a nationwide conversation on patent subject matter eligibility through a series of events and roundtables, and has now published a report presenting what we have learned from the public on this important issue. Some have raised concerns that the heightened bar for patent subject matter eligibility that resulted from these decisions has undermined the ability of intellectual property (IP) intensive industries to secure rights and investments in their innovations. Others have applauded the rulings for providing a useful tool in flushing out patents on technologies that they feel should not be patentable.”
“We are not sure where this is going; but we know for sure is that the likes of Watchtroll and corruptible former officials like Kappos (taking corporate money to lobby the former employer) will meddle and attempt to leverage their connections to bring software patents back, even in defiance of the US Supreme Court.”“When you only invite the patent industry, this is the kind of conclusions you get,” Henrion wrote about this report. We haven’t had time to examine it yet. Patent Buddy (pro software patents) linked to that and some people have gotten somewhat excited about it, perhaps thinking that the USPTO will magically undo Alice.
IBM’s Manny Schecter is among those who mentioned it and he promotes Watchtroll again, namely an article Robert Stoll wrote there. He “retired from the USPTO as Commissioner for Patents at the end of 2011,” by his own description/biography, but he is still meddling a lot, just like David Kappos (even while under IBM’s and Microsoft’s payroll).
We are not sure where this is going; but we know for sure is that the likes of Watchtroll and corruptible former officials like Kappos (taking corporate money to lobby the former employer) will meddle and attempt to leverage their connections to bring software patents back, even in defiance of the US Supreme Court. █
The Patent Microcosm Tries to Persuade the Headless USPTO to Crush Alice
In another effort to bring software patents back to the US (they are currently being swatted like flies in the courts), the lobby of the patent ‘industry’ gangs up with former officials of the USPTO — now in lobbying capacity — and a new report is issued regarding Section 101
Links 25/7/2017: KStars 2.8.0 is Out, Flash Will Die
Links for the day
How the EPO’s Terrible Decisions May Implicate the Government of Germany and Lufthansa
The role played by German authorities throughout the scandal involving Željko Topić, a notorious Vice-President at the European Patent Office (EPO)
Patent Maximalists Continue to Warp the Debate/Media Coverage About Patents in Britain
Just like in most places, including the English-speaking media in north America, British journalists omit voices of reason or simply give the podium to those seeking to increase the number of patent lawsuits (and breadth of these)
In 2017 Software Patents Are Barely Valid in the United States
Today’s simple reality is, even if the USPTO grants (or granted) a software patent, the prosecution certainty is notoriously low
Patent Troll Uniloc Lost a Software Patent Case Owing to PTAB, Microsoft-Connected Troll Finjan Holdings Keeps on Suing
The latest troll cases in the US and where they have gone (all about software patents, as usual)
Links 24/7/2017: Linux 4.13 RC2, Mesa 17.2 RC1, Akademy Coverage
Links for the day
Qualcomm-Apple Dispute Escalates Further (Lawsuits Come to Europe) With the Cost of Linux-Powered Devices Also at Stake
Another catchup with a high-profile case (complaints and lawsuits ad infinitum) that will help determine one’s ability to leverage patents in bulk — including software patents — against phone-making OEMs
Section 101/Alice: Latest News and Views
A § 101 change which effectively strikes out software patents (if not at the patent office, then in appeal boards and courts) continues to alter the litigation landscape much to the chagrin/regret of various circles
STRASBOURG: Representative of Lufthansa Accused of Corruption
According to some international sources, it was on account of the corrupt and criminal tendencies with which he has been endowed by nature and which he used to assist international corporations in protecting dubious patents in the Republic of Croatia that Željko Topić was rewarded with a position at the EPO in Munich, although his skills and mindset indicate that he does not belong there. This is also indicated by the fact that this complex-ridden individual recently changed his place of residence in Zagreb.
IBM and Watchtroll, Together With Microsoft, Among the Driving Forces for Resurgence of Software Patents
A look at who keeps lobbying against Alice and where/how; also our assessment of why such lobbying won’t be getting them anywhere any time soon
Alice/U.S.C. § 101 is a Done Deal, Meaning Software Patents Are Effectively Dead in the US
A look back at this summer’s patent cases where software patents are consistently (almost without exception) invalidated by courts, owing to § 101 (U.S.C./SCOTUS/Supreme Court)
Patents Roundup: Cisco and Arista, MP3 Liberated, and ‘Phone (Patent) Tax’ Estimated
Some of the very latest reports about patents in the US and how these impact the market (costs, availability, and viability of Free/Libre Open Source software)
Links 23/7/2017: Wine 2.13, Krita 3.2.0 Second Beta, KDE Applications 17.08 Beta, GNOME 3.25.4, Debian 9.1 and 8.9
Links for the day
Patent Troll MPEG-LA Expands From Software Patents to Patents on Life While USPTO is Virtually Headless
The travesty of software patents, such as patents on multimedia compression and playback, may soon be made worse as patents on genome are being aggregated by a notorious patent aggressor
Lack of Independence of the Boards of Appeal at the European Patent Organisation (EPO) a Fatal Blow for the UPC
Issues associated with the EPC, namely the lack of separation of powers at the EPO, may mean that the UPC is merely a zombie waiting to accept its permanent death
[DE] STRASBOURG: Vertreter der Lufthansa wegen Korruption angeklagt
Laut manche internationale Quellen wurde Željko Topić gerade wegen korruptiven und kriminellen Neigungen, mit welchen er von Natur begabt ist und mit welchen er den internationalen Korporationen beim Schutz von zwielichtigen Patenten in der Republik Kroatien geholfen hat, eigentlich belohnt mit der Arbeitsstelle in EPO in München, obwohl er laut seine Kenntnisse und seine Mentalität dorthin nicht gehört. Dafür spricht auch die Angabe, daß er als Person mit Komplexen neulich seinen Wohnsitz in Zagreb geändert hat.
Links 21/7/2017: New Wine, Ubuntu EoL
Links for the day
The Bizarre World of US Patents and Ongoing Pursuit/Granting of Software Patents in Spite of Section 101
A survey of recent patents that are either far too trivial, pertain purely to software, promote surveillance, or are pursued purely for vanity (when a court is likely to deem these invalid anyway)
Battistelli’s EPO Abuses May Soon Lead to the Death of the UPC and Return of the Old Order (‘EPO Glory’)
Having severely damaged the EPO, in a selfish effort to make Europe attractive to patent trolls and bullies, Team Battistelli gradually goes away along with the UPC
Links 20/7/2017: Qt Creator 4.4 Beta, Libgcrypt 1.8.0
Links for the day
Microsoft is Googlebombing “Linux” This Week in Order to Sell Proprietary Software That Does Not Run on GNU/Linux (and While Blackmailing OEMs Over Linux)
A reminder of the fact that Microsoft very much hates GNU/Linux, lobbies against it (e.g. in Munich), blackmails companies that distribute it (using software patents) and shares all data stored by its software through back doors (for access by the NSA and other Western spy agencies)
PTAB Persists and AIA Dominates in Spite of Smears and Bullying From Patent Extremists Including Watchtroll
The America Invents Act (AIA) and the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) maintain and gain prominence in spite of nefarious tactics of attack sites such as Watchtroll
Patent Reform in the United States is Led by the Supreme Court, Not Industrial Lobbies
Although lobbying by large corporations has served to change the patent landscape in the US, a lot of the big changes become possible because Justices with no vested interests (in patents and patent lawsuits) overturn decisions from the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit
Unified Patent Court (UPC): A Conspiracy of Lies and Silence
The impasse which makes impossible any progress on the Unified Patent Court (UPC) is simply being ignored — as if it never happened — by Team UPC
The British Government May be Pulling Out of the UPC Fantasy, Team UPC in Panic or Denial About It
The latest news about the UPC — news that Team UPC conveniently ignores — is that the British government “withdrew motion on Unified Patent Court with no notice”
Links 19/7/2017: MPV 0.26, Netrunner Rolling 2017.07
Links for the day
Links 18/7/2017: Sparky 5.0, Krita 3.2 Beta, Mageia 6, Slackware Turns 24
Links for the day
New Paper Explains Why UPC Ratification Efforts Have Been Just About as Corrupt as EPO Under Battistelli
Yesterday, Dr. Ingve Björn Stjerna revealed serious Constitutional issues with the campaign for the Unified Patent Court, which resembles an aggressive Battistelli-esque coup, not a democratic process by any stretch of imagination
Anti-Patent Trolls Reform in the US Evolves Nicely and Rogue Judges Get Named, Shamed
A quick look at today’s coverage regarding the battle against patent trolls in the US, as well as the patent microcosm’s war on the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB)